November 19, 2026
At 2042 Wiregrass Street in D.R. Horton's Captain's Cove, a five-bedroom, 2,043-square-foot single-story home is listed at $446,900, down from $469,885. On the same page, the floor plan behind that house, the Creekside, is listed as "starting in the $465s." As of mid-November 2026, that specific house on that specific lot was listed about $18,000 below the builder's starting price for a new Creekside.
That gap is the clearest pricing signal in Navarre new construction right now. In Captain's Cove, several homes listed by address are priced below their matching floor plans. In Herbst Homes' Buckeyes Landing, the one home that is already move-in ready is priced below identical homes still on the way. For buyers this season, the bigger question is when the house is ready, more than whether to choose new or resale.
Captain's Cove and Herbst Homes' Buckeyes Landing reached final plat approval within a month of each other. Santa Rosa County's subdivision record lists Buckeyes Landing as a 62-lot, 28.25-acre public subdivision in District 4, approved November 7, 2025. Captain's Cove is a 92-lot, 22.96-acre public subdivision in the same district, approved December 4, 2025.
Both sit near the US-98 and SR-87 corridor. Buckeyes Landing's homes are on Hatteras Drive and Viking Avenue. D.R. Horton's directions place Captain's Cove a couple of miles along US-98 after you turn east from SR-87, with a community address of 2108 Wiregrass Street. A year after approval, the two are selling the same way. Each builder lists a short run of individual homes by address, and each of those homes carries its own price.
D.R. Horton's Captain's Cove page shows eight homes for sale and a longer list marked under contract, along with six floor plans and their starting prices. When you match each available home to the plan with the same layout and square footage, a pattern shows up.
| Address | Size and layout | Listed price | Matching plan's starting price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2042 Wiregrass St | 2,043 sq ft, 5 bed, 1 story | $446,900, reduced from $469,885 | Creekside, in the $465s |
| 2034 Wiregrass St | 2,043 sq ft, 5 bed, 1 story | $459,900 | Creekside, in the $465s |
| 2013 Wiregrass St | 2,296 sq ft, 4 bed, 2 story | $454,900 | Belfort, in the $475s |
| 2038 Wiregrass St | 1,799 sq ft, 4 bed, 1 story | $439,900 | Beau, in the $445s |
| 2026 Wiregrass St | 1,799 sq ft, 4 bed, 1 story | $444,900 | Beau, in the $445s |
The two-story home at 2013 Wiregrass is listed about $20,000 under the Belfort's starting price. The two Beau-sized homes are within a few thousand dollars of that plan's base or just under it. The entry point for the community is 2022 Wiregrass, a three-bedroom, 1,580-square-foot single-story home at $409,900.
Price per square foot changes a lot across that list. The $409,900 home works out to about $259 a square foot, the reduced Creekside to about $219, and the 2,296-square-foot two-story at 2013 Wiregrass to about $198. In Captain's Cove this season, the larger listed homes cost less per foot than the smallest one.
The under-contract list matters too. Twelve homes in Captain's Cove are marked under contract, on Wiregrass Street and Noleka Court, and most are the same 1,580-, 1,799-, 2,043- and 2,296-square-foot layouts still for sale. The homes still for sale are the same layouts buyers have already been signing for, and some are now listed below their plan's starting price.
Herbst Homes lists nine available homes in Buckeyes Landing, priced from $439,900 to $589,900 and built on four of its five floor plans. Each listing has a date attached, and those dates run from move-in ready now through spring.
| Address | Plan and size | Price | Ready |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7595 Hatteras Dr | Turquoise, 2,711 sq ft | $574,900 | Move-in ready |
| 7507 Hatteras Dr | Ruby, 2,483 sq ft | $544,900 | December 2, 2026 |
| 7511 Hatteras Dr | Turquoise, 2,711 sq ft | $589,900 | December 9, 2026 |
| 7515 Hatteras Dr | Ruby, 2,483 sq ft | $544,900 | December 16, 2026 |
| 7527 Hatteras Dr | Turquoise, 2,711 sq ft | $589,900 | January 27, 2027 |
| 7524 Hatteras Dr | Carlos, 1,880 sq ft | $439,900 | February 24, 2027 |
| 7528 Hatteras Dr | Turquoise, 2,711 sq ft | $589,900 | March 3, 2027 |
| 3485 Viking Ave | Carlos, 1,880 sq ft | $439,900 | March 25, 2027 |
| 3479 Viking Ave | Sapphire, 2,404 sq ft | $529,900 | April 2, 2027 |
The Turquoise rows show the same direction as Wiregrass Street. The move-in-ready Turquoise at 7595 Hatteras Drive is listed at $574,900. Three more Turquoise homes with the same 2,711 square feet, five bedrooms and three baths are listed at $589,900, with completion dates from December 2026 into March 2027. The house a buyer can move into today costs $15,000 less than the identical ones still being built.
For a household moving on military orders, or one selling a current home in the spring, the calendar works like a second price list. A buyer who needs to close before the holidays and a buyer who needs keys in late March can both find a Herbst home with a matching date. They will pay different prices for the same square footage, depending on how far along the house is.
The two builders list a $439,900 home at the same price but estimate the monthly payment very differently. D.R. Horton shows $2,946.42 a month for 2038 Wiregrass Street. Herbst shows $2,373.68 a month for 7524 Hatteras Drive. That is a gap of about $573 a month for the same purchase price.
D.R. Horton's payment calculator lets you choose conventional loans at 5, 10 or 20 percent down or VA at zero down, with 15- or 30-year terms, and it has separate lines for taxes, mortgage insurance, home insurance and HOA dues. Its disclaimer says plainly: "This is NOT a loan offer. D.R. Horton, the seller, is not a lender and does not offer financing." It adds that "Property Taxes, Home Insurance, Mortgage Insurance and Homeowners' Association Dues are estimates in the community or locality where the property is located." A buyer comparing Captain's Cove with Buckeyes Landing will get a fairer picture from one lender quote on both homes, with the same down payment and loan type, than from either builder's estimate. These figures are general information as of mid-November 2026, not financial advice, so confirm your own numbers with a lender before you decide.
Holiday Builders is advertising its own promotion, which shows how builders across the region are approaching the end of the year. In an October 7, 2026 post, the builder advertised "special low-interest rates" on select move-in-ready homes in Florida for qualified buyers who use First Heritage Mortgage. Contracts must be written by December 31, 2026 and close within 40 days, and the offer can't be combined with others. Holiday's Navarre page lists a move-in-ready Eden at 1940 Sunrise Drive for $689,538, with build-on-your-lot options and builder homesites. Ask the builder directly which homes the promotion covers. Across all three builders this winter, the price cuts and special terms are attached to homes that already exist on a lot.
Resideline's snapshot of ZIP code 32566, dated November 16, 2026, puts the median price of tracked closed sales over the past six months at $435,000. The middle half of those sales ran from $330,000 to $540,000. Resideline describes those 556 closed sales as a tracked sample, not every sale in the ZIP. The same snapshot counts 160 active listings and 11 pending sales, with a median asking price of $539,950. The median active listing had been on the market 109 days.
Set against those figures, nine of the 17 homes listed across the two communities fall within the middle half of recent Navarre resale prices. Those are the six Captain's Cove homes from $409,900 to $459,900 and the three Buckeyes Landing homes at $439,900 and $529,900. The Ruby and Turquoise homes in Buckeyes Landing, from $544,900 to $589,900, sit above the $540,000 top of that range. Only the $409,900 entry home in Captain's Cove is below the six-month median. For a buyer weighing an older resale against one of those nine homes, the prices are close, and a reduced price on a home already listed narrows the gap further. For a broader look at the choice, see our guide to new construction vs. resale in Navarre.
For a lower entry point in new construction, D.R. Horton's Enclave at Midtown, off SR-87 South, has attached townhomes. One at 8558 Midtown Court is listed at $279,900, down from $301,900.
Two listings on Wiregrass Street are priced far above the rest. 1944 Wiregrass is a 2,200-square-foot, two-story, four-bedroom home at $999,900. 1958 Wiregrass is 2,114 square feet at $959,900. Neither has a garage. They are the Bradford and Monroe plans, which start at $1.00 million and in the $960s, and another Monroe-sized home at 1950 Wiregrass is marked under contract. D.R. Horton describes Captain's Cove as "right on the water." If either of these homes is on your list, ask the sales office what sets those lots apart before you compare them with the rest of the community.
Are new homes in Navarre always priced at the floor plan's starting price? No. As of mid-November 2026, several homes listed by address in Captain's Cove were listed below the starting prices of their matching plans. In Buckeyes Landing, the move-in-ready Turquoise was listed $15,000 below identical homes due in December through March.
Which homes are ready soonest? In Buckeyes Landing, 7595 Hatteras Drive is listed as move-in ready, and three more homes have completion dates in December 2026. The rest are scheduled from late January through April 2, 2027.
Can I compare the builders' monthly payment estimates? Not side by side. The two builders' estimates for a $439,900 home differ by about $573 a month, and only D.R. Horton's page lays out the inputs its calculator uses. One lender quote on both homes gives a cleaner comparison.
If you're weighing a listed home on Wiregrass Street against one on Hatteras Drive that won't be ready until spring, Shelby A Baker can help you put each builder's ready dates and prices side by side before you commit. Schedule a consultation and we'll walk through the homes that fit your timeline.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact Shelby today to discuss all your real estate needs!